Pompei Pizza Restaurant, located in Rocky Point, NY, stands out as a beloved pizza establishment with consistently positive reviews from patrons. Diners rave about the smooth service, even during peak hours. Paul C highlights the impressive efficiency of the staff on a bustling Friday night, noting the excellent Sicilian pizza and the appealing presentation of their pies. The garlic knots also get a special mention, which adds to the vibrant atmosphere of the restaurant.
Victoria’s praise for the restaurant's beautiful new décor complements Makayla’s sentiment about the large portions and the delightful taste of the pizza, ensuring a satisfying dining experience. Customers can expect classic Italian dishes, with the freshly renovated ambiance enhancing the overall experience.
A standout item is the Chicken and Broccoli Rabe Panini, which Matthew describes as one of the best sandwiches he has ever tasted, showcasing the restaurant’s diverse menu. Furthermore, community engagement shines through as Jessica recounts her nostalgic experience participating in a pizza-making field trip, reinforcing Pompei's commitment to family and local ties.
Gathering these delightful impressions, Pompei Pizza Restaurant delivers more than just great food; it serves an enriching community experience that invites everyone for a classic slice of Italy.
Amenities and More
Service options
Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Small plates
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Parking
Photos
Reviews For Pompei Pizza Restaurant
Paul C
Jun 20,2025
These guys were running very smooth on a Friday night. With a full oven of to-go pies, and a few dozen online pick-ups they still had a nice selection of slices. Garlic knots looked tremendous. Presentation of sauce and cheese was alternating instead of layered on Sicilian pies. Very good overall slices. The service was atypically smooth. You could just tell nobody was stressed when it was very busy. That's a testament to knowing what you are doing.
Victoria
Jun 17,2025
They have redecorated and it looks beautiful. Great sicilian pizza.
makayla gilberg
Jun 13,2025
I love this place so much! The portions are huge and pizza tastes amazing! Even after the remodel, everything is exactly the same and better than ever! I would recommend this to anyone wanting a good classic Italian dish and an amazing slice of pizza!!
Matthew Cutalo
Jun 3,2025
The Chicken and broccoli rabe panini is one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten
Jessica Falzone
May 18,2025
Appreciation post!!! Yesterday was so much fun. My life came full circle and I got to chaperone a field trip to Pompeii Pizzeria !!! I actually had the letter of working at this establishment many many moons ago! Vinny Vincent-Catherine Prestigiacomo does this field trip at no cost to the parents and opens the restaurant four hours so he could teach 21st graders how to make a pizza!!! Each kiddo received a Pompei T-shirt so they didn’t get their clothes messy. They’re very own mini pizza box with their name on it and somebody took a great deal of time cutting pepperoni in each child’s initials so that they were sure to get the exact pizza that they made. if you use Pompei for your regular go to Friday night Pizza you need to because this is a family establishment that gives back to the community and has hands-down the best pizza not to mention rice balls! Thank you Vinny, and the staff at Pompeii for all you do!
Lynn L
Apr 15,2025
My Aunt is in town from Tampa with her great grandson. We of course had to get NY pizza! My young cousin got to experience the sites and aromas of an authentic pizza place... It always smells delicious at Pompei. Great pizza! The counter person who served us was so accommodating and helpful. Thank you! PS: can't wait to see the new dining room!
Desiree Finley (DezzyLoo)
Apr 11,2025
Came in and the man was singing, "That's Amore" Beautiful display case. I love how my sandwhich came.in a paper box. I'm excited we live close.
Richard D
Mar 23,2025
We had a great waitress named Kimberly who was quick and knowledgeable .the food was delicious and the portions were huge . If you are in rocky point and want a good meal. Go to Pompeii’s you won’t be disappointed I recommend the eggplant rolatini
Reviews For Pompei Pizza Restaurant